| Site Id: | 3.58.1 |
| Rating: | 2 stars |
| Address: | 754 Montauk Highway |
| Location: | Islip, New York 11751, USA |
| Lat/Lng: | 40.73013, -73.20629 |
| Building status: | Extant |
| 3.58.1.1: | Redmond Memorial Window: St. John (1896) (Extant) |
| 3.58.1.2: | Johnson Memorial Window: Choir of Angels (1898) (Extant) |
| 3.58.1.3: | Hyde Memorial Window: Recording Angel (1900) (Extant) |
| 3.58.1.4: | Peters Memorial Window: Resurrection Lilies (1899) (Extant) |
| 3.58.1.5: | St. Mark (1880) (Removed) |
| 3.58.1.6: | St. Mark (1890) (Extant) |
| 3.58.1.7: | trefoil (1880) (Extant) |
| 3.58.1.8: | bullseye rondel windows (Partly extant) |
| 3.58.1.9: | Christ with hands outstretched (1888) (Unknown) |